1. Title of project: El Hoyo - Monte Galan Geothermal Project
2. Host country: Nicaragua
3. Brief project description:
The El Hoyo-Monte Galan Geothermal Project involves the construction and operation of a 70 megawatt (MW)
geothermal plant that is designed to meet the demand for increased electricity supply in Nicaragua. Since
this demand would otherwise be met by using diesel fuel, which is the predominant and also the most
inexpensive electricity fuel source in Nicaragua, the flash-steam project reduces carbon dioxide
(CO2) emissions associated with fossil fuel combustion. The geothermal project will have a 70 MW
unit that is expected to come on-line in 2001. An additional 35 MW unit may be constructed in 2004, if a
larger reservoir of geothermal resources is confirmed in the project site. The emission reduction estimates
are based on displacement of a diesel fueled unit with a geothermal unit of equal capacity.
4. Participants:
Name of Organization or Individual
Country
C and R, Inc.
Nicaragua
Trans-Pacific Geothermal Corporation (TGC)
U.S.A.
Item
Organization
Name of organization (original language)
or
Name of individual if unaffiliated with any organization
C and R, Inc.
Name of organization (English)
(Same as above)
Acronym (original language)
None
Acronym (English)
None
Department
Function(s) within the AIJ project activities
Street
P.O. Box 2114
City
Managua
State
Post code
Country
Nicaragua
Telephone
505-2-666166
Fax
505-2-666165
E-mail
World Wide Web-URL address
Administrative Officer Responsible for the Project
Surname
McGregor
First name, middle name
Roberto
Job title
President
Direct telephone
505-2-666166
Direct fax
505-2-666165
Direct e-mail
Contact Person for AIJ Activities (if different from the Administrative Officer)
Surname
First name, middle name
Job title
Direct telephone
Direct fax
Direct e-mail
Item
Organization
Name of organization (original language)
or
Name of individual if unaffiliated with any organization
Administrative Officer Responsible for the Project
Surname
Meidav
First name, middle name
Dr. Tsvi
Job title
President and CEO
Direct telephone
510-763-7812
Direct fax
510-763-2504
Direct e-mail
Contact Person for AIJ Activities (if different from the Administrative Officer)
Surname
First name, middle name
Job title
Direct telephone
Direct fax
Direct e-mail
5. Description of AIJ project activities
Item
Type of Project
Sector(s)
Energy
Primary activity(ies)
Alternative energy generation (geothermal)
Project Location
Country
Nicaragua
Exact location (city, state, region)
45 kilometers (km) northwest of Managua
Key Dates and Current Stage of Project
Project starting date (month/year)
January 1999
Project ending date (month/year)
June 2036
Project lifetime (years)
37 years and 6 months
Current stage of project
Mutually agreed
General Project Description and Technical Data
The El Hoyo-Monte Galan Geothermal Project involves construction and operation of a 70 MW
geothermal power facility at El Hoyo-Monte Galan, 45 kilometers northwest of Managua. The
flash-steam geothermal development will displace equivalent size diesel-based electricity
generation.
Exploration and development of the resource plant began in January 1997, and is expected to be
completed by mid-2001. Facilities will include a 70 MW power plant, roads, pipelines, wells, and
storage and office facilities. The project's feasibility stage, which involved conducting
detailed geoscientific studies began in October 1995 and was completed in January 1997.
6. Cost
(a) Explanation of methodology for calculating cost data
Methodology for Calculating Cost Data
This information is not yet available.
(b) Cost data-Project development
Itemized Project Development Costs
(c) Cost data-Project implementation
The estimated total cost for 70 MW power plant development is about $130 million. No precise information on
project costs will be available until the thermodynamic characteristics of the reservoir fluids and the
productivity of the wells are determined through long-term testing.
7. Monitoring and verification of AIJ project activities and results
Item
Party(ies) that will be monitoring project activities
Trans-Pacific Geothermal Corporation (TGC), or a partnership formed by TGC to construct and operate
the project
Party(ies) that will be externally verifying project results
This information is not yet available (see below).
Date when the monitoring plan became (or will become) operational (month/year)
January 2001
Types of data that will be collected
See below.
Description of Monitoring and Verification Activities and Schedule for Implementation
Monitoring of potential pollution is provided in two distinct stages: (a) during well testing, and
(b) during plant operations. Monitoring of gas emissions is routinely conducted in an operating
geothermal project. This is done by (a) measuring the fraction of non-condensable gases in the
steam flow, and (b) sending representative samples of non-condensable gas for analysis at a
reputable laboratory. Gas analysis will be conducted frequently in the early years of the project,
and less frequently in the later years, as the reservoir becomes stabilized. In many classical
reservoirs, the non-condensable gas fraction declines over time.
No external verification has been arranged. The party(ies) responsible for conducting external
verification activities will be designated as a normal part of the operation and administration of
the project.
B. Governmental approval
Item
Please check one of the following.
This report is a first report.
or
This report is an
intermediate report.
or
This report is a final report.
Please check one of the following:
This report is a joint
report. Letter(s) of approval of this report from the designated national authority of the other
Party(ies) involved in the activity is(are) attached in Section J, Annex.
or
This report is a separate report.
Additional comments (if any):
C. Compatibility with, and supportiveness of, national economic development and socioeconomic and
environmental priorities and strategies
Compatibility with Economic Development and Socioeconomic and Environmental Priorities
At the Summit of the Americas in Miami, Florida in December 1994, the Government of Nicaragua
presented a plan for developing Nicaragua's geothermal potential. The plan outlined steps to
meet the goal to develop 500 MW of geothermal power in the next 10 to 12 years. The El Hoyo - Monte
Galan Geothermal Project is consistent with this national plan.
In the spirit of the previous agreements among Central American leaders, and the CONCAUSA
declaration at the Summit of the Americas, Nicaragua is one of the first Central American countries
to come up with a preliminary plan for development of their renewable energy resources.
D. Environmental, social/cultural, and economic impacts of the AIJ project
Non-Greenhouse-Gas Environmental Impacts of the Project
The development and generation of thermal energy generally has a minimal impact on the environment,
and when compared with fossil fuel-based energy sources, has no significant emissions of GHG. The
project will utilize less than 50 acres of land for all purposes, and the site chosen is sparsely
populated.
The amount of CO2, sulfur oxides (SOx), and nitrogen oxides (NOx)
emitted into the atmosphere from a geothermal resource varies from 0 to 2 percent of that emitted
from a fuel oil-based resource. The U.S. Department of Energy (U.S. DOE) has estimated that a
geothermal resource typically emits 0.16 kg SOx/MWh, compared to 4.99 kg
SOx/MWh from an oil-based resource. GHG emissions from plant construction activities
will be short term and transitory. The hydrogen sulfide content at El Hoyo is not expected to
exceed acceptable EPA standards. This assumption is based on 12 years of experience in producing
geothermal fluids in the adjacent Volcan Momotombo area, around 15 km away from the El Hoyo site.
Social/Cultural Impacts of the Project
Only half of the population of Nicaragua is currently connected to a source of electricity at this
time. Availability of a more stable supply of electricity from the El Hoyo project will help to
increase living standards, education, and health in Nicaragua.
Economic Impacts of the Project
Nicaragua currently suffers from severe blackouts (up to nine hours per day) because of drought in
recent years, which has reduced the output of the hydroelectric plants (which normally provide
about 26% of the country's electricity), increased the cost of electricity production, and
diminished the interest of industries in developing new projects in the country.
According to the U.S. Geothermal Energy Association, Nicaragua has a 4,000 MW geothermal power
potential. Using its abundant geothermal resources, Nicaragua seeks to reduce its dependence on
imported fuel and unreliable hydro power by furthering sustainable energy development. Nicaragua
would benefit from increased stabilization of its base-load power, resulting in increased
productivity in the workplace and the economy as a whole.
In addition to its own use, Nicaragua could potentially export power from its geothermal sources to
other countries in the region, thereby displacing fossil fuel-based power and improving the overall
air quality in Central America. The recently concluded agreement between the Central American
countries to construct an interconnected transmission system within the foreseeable future greatly
increases the potential for export of power from Nicaragua to adjacent countries. Segments of that
grid already exist, and others will be constructed as a result of the new pact.
The long-term operation of the El Hoyo project facility will provide employment opportunities to
the community. In addition, the project will provide economic benefits from secondary and tertiary
activities associated with the facility. Typically a 70 MW power plant employs 60 to 100 workers on
a full time basis. No potential negative impacts are foreseen.
E. Greenhouse gas impacts of the AIJ project
1. Scenario description
Item
Site Designation
Site number (order of presentation in this report)
1 of 1
Site name/designation
El Hoyo-Monte Galan Geothermal Project
Project sector
Energy
Reference Scenario
Primary activity(ies)
Electricity generation from fossil fuels
Has the reference scenario changed since the last report? (If yes, explain any changes below.)
Yes
No
This is the first project report.
Description:
In the absence of the geothermal project, it is assumed by the developer that diesel fuel would
have been used to meet increased electricity demand. The reference case, therefore, is based on GHG
emissions from diesel-fueled units with generation capacities equal to those of the geothermal
units in the project scenario (70 MW with an 85 percent load factor).
Predicted Project Scenario
Primary activity(ies)
Alternative energy generation (geothermal)
Description:
Flash-steam geothermal plants emit small amounts of CO2 that is produced when the steam
separates from boiling water. Because the geothermal plant fully displaces diesel fuel, the only
emissions in the project scenario are those associated with geothermal electricity
generation.
The 70 MW geothermal plant will begin operation in 2001. If a large reservoir of geothermal
resources is confirmed, the plant capacity may be increased by another 35 MW in 2004. It is assumed
that the geothermal plant will have a 35-year lifetime, with an 85 percent load factor throughout
its lifetime.
Description of Calculation Methodology for the Reference Scenario
The reference case is based on GHG emissions from diesel fueled units with generation capacities
and a load factor equal to that of the geothermal units in the project scenario (70 MW with an 85
percent load factor). Only CO2, the major GHG emitted from diesel fuel combustion, is
included in the calculations, and emissions per MWh are assumed to remain constant over the
lifetime of the project. Emissions in 1999 through January 2001 are zero because the first
geothermal unit is not expected to come on line until mid-2001.
Annual electricity generation (MWh) is calculated by multiplying total plant capacity by the number
of hours in a year and by a load factor of 85 percent. For example, in the year 2001, only the 70
MW unit is in operation, and annual electricity generation equals 521,220 MWh (= 70 MW * 8,760
hours * 85% load factor). Load factor is defined as the ratio of the average to peak loads.
Annual GHG emissions are calculated by multiplying annual electricity generation by a diesel fuel
CO2 emission factor of 0.723214 t CO2/MWh, (which was taken from a Public
Service Commission of Nevada Ruling, SB 497, Docket No. 89-752). For example, emissions in 2002 are
376,954 t CO2 (= 521,220 MWh * 0.723214 t CO2/MWh).
Description of Calculation Methodology for the Project Scenario
The only emissions in the project scenario are the small amounts of CO2 produced during
flash-steam geothermal electricity generation. Emissions per MWh are assumed to remain constant
over the lifetime of the project. Project emissions are projected to begin by mid-2001, when the 70
MW plant comes on line, and then may increase in the latter half of 2004 if an additional 35 MW
plant also comes on line.
Annual flash-steam geothermal electricity generation (MWh) is calculated by multiplying total plant
capacity by the number of hours in a year and by a load factor of 85 percent. For example, in 2002
only the 70 MW unit is in operation, and annual electricity generation equals 521,220 MWh (= 70 MW
* 8,760 hours * 85% load factor). The assumed load factor is conservative given that geothermal
plants can have load factors of greater than 90 percent.
Annual emissions from the flash-steam geothermal plant are calculated by multiplying annual
electricity generation (MWh) by a geothermal CO2 emission factor of approximately
0.000893 t CO2/MWh (which was taken from a Public Service Commission of Nevada Ruling,
SB 497, Docket No. 89-752). For example, emissions in 2002 are 465 t CO2 (= 521,220 MWh
* 0.000893 t CO2/MWh ).
Description of Calculation Methodology for the Actual Project
This information is not yet available.
3. GHG emission/sequestration data
(a) Reporting of GHG emissions/sequestration
(b) Additional information on GHG emissions/sequestration
Indirect or Secondary GHG Impacts (Positive and Negative)
The El Hoyo project will generate an insignificant amount of greenhouse gases. Power generation
from the project will displace diesel fuels and will therefore reduce emissions that would
otherwise worsen the air quality in Nicaragua.
Factors That Could Cause the Future Loss or Reversal of GHG Benefits
Given the nature of this project-substitution of fossil fuel generated power with geothermal
power-loss or reversal of benefits that have been achieved is not possible.
The only factors that may result in projected benefits not being achieved would be those that
reduce the effectiveness of the geothermal plant over time. The most likely factor that could cause
a decline in output from the project is exhaustion of the hydrothermal reservoir. However, the
converse is equally possible; the reservoir may turn out to be substantially larger than that is
expected. In that case, the amount of fossil fuel displacement may be greater than the amount
indicated in this report. Although the project facility has been designed to match the hydrothermal
reservoir, this cannot be guaranteed.
Other potential uncertainties that may affect GHG estimates include volcanological uncertainties,
regulatory risk, and political uncertainties.
Strategy for Reducing the Risk of Future Loss or Reversal of GHG Benefits
This information is not yet available.
F. Funding of the AIJ project
1. Identification of funding sources
(a) Funding sources for project development
Funding Source
Country ofFunding Source
Amount
($US)
Percentof TotalFunding (%)
International Fund for Renewable Energy and Efficiency (IFREE)
U.S.A.
California Energy Commission (CEC)
U.S.A.
Trans-Pacific Geothermal Corporation (TGC)
U.S.A.
300,000
Trade Development Agency (TDA)
U.S.A.
Government of Nicaragua (GON)
Nicaragua
Total
100
(b) Funding sources for project implementation
Funding Source
Country ofFunding Source
Amount
($US)
Percentof TotalFunding
(%)
Is This Funding Assured? (Y/N)
International Finance Corporation (IFC)
Multilateral
N
Oxbow Power Corporation
U.S.A.
N
Calpine Corporation
U.S.A.
N
Atkinson Corporation
U.S.A.
N
Total
100
2. Assessment of additional funding needs
Current or Planned Activities to Obtain Additional Funding
This information is not yet available.
G. Contribution to capacity building and technology transfer
Contribution to Capacity Building and Technology Transfer
The El Hoyo project will facilitate the transfer of renewable technologies because the developers
will provide training to local personnel in the operation and maintenance of the project.
H. Recent developments, technical difficulties, and obstacles encountered
Recent Project Developments
This information is not yet available.
Technical Difficulties and Other Obstacles Encountered
This information is not yet available.
I. Additional information
Additional Information
This information is not yet available.
J. Annex
1. Host country acceptance of the AIJ project
Country/Project Title
Name, Title, and Government Agencyof the DesignatedNational Authority
Date of Approval(day/month/year)
Nicaragua/El Hoyo-Monte Galan Geothermal Project
José A. Ley L., Minister, Nicaraguan Institute of Energy